Thursday, April 21, 2011
The Insider by Reece Hirsch
Book: The Insider
Author: Reece Hirsch
Grade: B-/C+ (maybe I should start giving % ratings out of 100) This would be 72%
Recommended To: Legal Thriller and action fans. Outsiders.
I tried to win this book on Goodreads, failed and waited forrrevaaaa to get it on paperbackswap.com. Finally it comes, and I read it in a day. It is the fastest I've read a book this year that is of any substantial length. It seems that the font used for this book was especially huge; I might have gotten the "large print" version.
This book follows big law firm associate/partner Will Connelly in his short journey through the world of insider trading, the Russian mafia, and a potential murder charge.
Here's what I liked: This was a quick book and what I classify as a "train read." Super fast, easy, doesn't require a lot of thought. This is the first book by Reece Hirsch and it was a solid first effort. He probably has a promising future as an author as long as he sticks to what he knows, cuts down some of the character dialogue, and doesn't try to cram too much stuff in one book.
The plot was okay. It often seemed like a HUGE stretch that a partner at a big firm would be knocked for insider trading, possible terrorism, murder, and connections to the Russian mob and all because he was set up to take the fall. This could probably have been four books instead of one. With all of the plot lines and twists it was hard to keep track of what was going on.
Here's what I didn't like: The main character! He was so dumb sometimes. If the Russian Mob tells you that they are going to extort you, then you DO NOT under any circumstances leave your busy law office with them. What is wrong with this guy. He's so smart sometimes because he figures out all of the tenuous connections between terrorists, mobsters, partners, etc. but he does some mega dumb things, like go to the Russian restaurant that serves as the headquarters of the mafia. Alone. As in - by himself. Foolish.
Connelly was also a very flat character. Hirsch tried to give him dimension, but sometimes in these action based novels it is better not to pretend that the characters are substantive. The effort at substance highlighted that Connelly was flatter than ever. Jack Bauer - not very substantive. Excellent show? Yes.
I also didn't like the fight scene at the end. Without giving too much away at one point the main dude and some other guy are circling each other with a hammer and a screwdriver respectively. What? The mental image I got from this was so funny I had to laugh out loud.
I get that this is a first novel - and it was a solid first effort by Hirsch, but I think there were some serious plot fails that took away the story as a whole. I enjoyed reading this book overall and if you are looking for something fast from a new and promising author - then you should check out this book.